MAJOR SWe3:ROTS PLOT SPOILERS AHEAD -- YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED!!
Went with the family to see Star Wars III last night -- oy, what a waste of $39! It was every bit the huge disappointment I had feared. 2.5 hours with only a couple of momentary points of good storytelling. It should have been so great -- the theme of a good man's descent into evil made me want to watch Lawrence of Arabia and Citizen Kane again, or read Heart of Darkness. And the parallel theme of a democratic society degenerating into empire, "ripped from today's headlines" as they say, could have had a great epic sweep, but this movie has no meat on its bones; it was like watching a comic book on the screen. Anakin's reasons for siding with Palpatine are exasperatingly unconvincing -- "I had these bad dreams, so I'll turn to evil!" -- "If I hack up these here Jedi kids you'll teach me how to defeat death, right?" -- "Oops, you tricked me into letting you kill Mace Windu -- what have I done? Oh, right, I've become your apprentice -- well, that's cool. Who should I betray next, master?"
And watching Natalie Portman try to act was just excruciating. I was almost grateful when Young Darth did his remote-strangulation thing on her, just to shut her up -- maybe my mind is being twisted by the dark side, too...
I did enjoy the moment where Young Darth says to Obi Wan "If you're not with us, then you're my enemy" -- with its obvious dig at Dumbya. But I couldn't believe Darth's anguished "NOOOOOOOOOO!!!" when Palpatine tells him that he killed Padme; it was just too much of a movie cliche -- there was laughter in the audience -- I mean, was it a reference to the scene in Toy Story 2 where Buzz finds out that Zurg is his father?
The movie left a lot of loose ends frustratingly untied: Why does Leia grow up to be a "Princess" if she's being raised by an exiled former Senator? When/where/how does Chewy meet up with Han Solo (who is never mentioned). Who is Uncle Owen, how does Obi Wan know or find him, and what's his (and his nameless wife's) relationship to Anakin's dead mom? What does the population of the galaxy think about all these goings-on at the summit of power in Trantor, I mean Coruscant. Isn't there ANYONE else in the Senate (besides Bail and Padme) who try to resist Palpatine's power grab?
I was also really hoping for a few scenes of gritty future-city life at street level (as in Blade Runner, Fifth Element and Total Recall, and as at least attempted in Episode II), but most of the plot seems to take place on the 500th floor. But at least Lucas & Co. has given us all something to complain about.
At KillerMovies Community Forums > Star Wars > Star Wars: Episode III, starwarsfreak34 suggests a fascinating idea:
palps [Palapatine's] word about the manipulation of the force by [Darth] plageuis (SP?) could this be how anakin came about? my theory is, if it is, that anakin's destiny was NOT to destroy the sith and bring balance to the force that way. the balance is upset because he wasn't meant to be alive at the time and the equilibrium was upset, thus he had to DIE to bring balance to the Force.




